I think there’s a lot of intellectual dishonesty that goes on in the Biblical slavery discussion. And I think the dishonesty goes both ways, from Christian apologists like Tim Keller who want all biblical slavery to be analogous to forms of labor we find morally fine to those who think the biblical text doesn’t put forward the worldview that ultimately brought down slavery. There’s a lot that could be said here, and a lot that still needs to be said about slavery and Christianity, but I’m focusing on a small part of the discussion here. Because it just occurred to me why biblical slavery doesn’t bother me, and never really has.
Capitalism is viewed as evil by certain segments of our society, usually by segments that ironically have benefited the most from Capitalism. I love listening to woke podcasters like Sarah Marshall blame everything on capitalism when her livelihood is entirely dependent on capitalism. But she’s not entirely wrong. Christianity and capitalism are more compatible than Christianity and actual socialism (not just advanced welfare states, which are often confused with socialism) but Christianity, and Conservatism broadly speaking, is not exactly pro capitalist. More pro capitalist than pro socialist, that’s for sure. But Christianity doesn’t come with an economic system built into its worldview. Greed is not good for the Christian, greed and the love of wealth are evil. The Christian west built capitalism with Christian principles but we could have built a very different system with many of those same principles. A much more agrarian, less technological and more conservative system. We could’ve built a kind of Christian socialist system, it would’ve had many of the same problems of actual socialism. But what we built was a very liberal system, a system that ultimately undermined the Christian values that created it.
This is why biblical laws about slavery don’t bother me. We didn’t know some of the problems capitalism would create, and we couldn’t anticipate that elites would continue to love socialism even after it was defeated. Humans are not great at this economics and justice stuff. So why didn’t God give us the ideal economic system in scripture, I’m not entirely sure, but my guess is that would be completely contrary to the purpose of scripture. We would’ve become all about economics instead of God, truth and love. It’s very telling that socialists, real communists, truly believe socialism is love. It’s taken the place of God for them.
Consider primogeniture. This ancient law privileged the eldest son in the family so that he would receive all the family inheritance and become the next patriarch. This ensured that the family’s wealth would be protected both practically and legally and the entire family would benefit and be protected from poverty. We look at this and see it as immoral, not so much because we can actually economically critique it but because it conflicts with our values of equality, values that come from Christianity. Because basically every time God gets the chance to pick a son he doesn’t pick the elder son. He undermines a system that actually worked very well in the ancient world. Sometimes, like with Hagar or the Exodus, he even picks slaves and women.
It makes perfect sense why it worked (and actually would still work incredibly well in our culture) because wealth was property, not just land but cattle, slaves, etc. Money existed but it wasn’t true wealth. We think of wealth as money but even in our society the most valuable thing is still property, meaning physical land. It’s one of the most invisibly unjust things about our government systems is that the actual owning of land is almost impossible anymore, most of the time people own houses but not land, which means the public is basically defrauded by the very government that constantly taxes them by giving them the illusion of property. But houses still appreciate in value in a very real and powerful way that money does not. A house that was worth 80k in 2010 could easily be worth well over 500k today. Houses are property, not as concrete as land but still real property and that makes them real wealth. (PS I’m not mentioning gold because I honestly don’t understand why precious metals work the way they do as permanent sources of wealth and value, but for whatever reason a lot of the principles of property apply to precious metals) Given inflation that’s not quite the value it would’ve been in a different era but it’s based in real value. Maintaining property within a family via the eldest son (or daughter or whoever) would be a great way to increase familial wealth. We actually impoverish ourselves by not using primogeniture and constantly splitting wealth. So then why would God give us values that undermine primogeniture? Why would He give laws that regulate slavery then tell a story culminating in Christ that makes slavery unthinkable everywhere it goes?
Big surprise: God doesn’t care about what you care about. Good economics are dangerous to the soul, but sadly so is poverty. Christian vows of poverty are taken within a system of wealth and power. Actual poverty leads to death (which is one reason we have almost no actual poverty in the west, western homeless have near constant access to high calorie foods, another product of capitalism). As Jesus told Pilate His Kingdom is not of this world. The point of God’s story was never economic happenstance, like slavery or capitalism. The point of God’s story is eternal love, not material benefit.
Look at the parable of the prodigal son. Economics play a huge part of that story and we rarely think about it. When the younger son goes to the father and asks for his inheritance he is saying not just that he hates the father and wants him to die but that he hates the family and wants to impoverish it. The elder brother is justly angry with him, because his sin of selfishness wasn’t just against the patriarch but against him and the entire family. Because now the father would have to sell part of their property to give the younger brother his inheritance. A good father in that society would have beaten a son that said something like that. And a good elder brother probably would’ve helped him. And when I say beat, I don’t mean spank. I mean that those two men would’ve had a moral duty to pummel the younger brother, painful and hurtful. Poverty meant death. Death was on the line, and the hearers of Jesus’ parable would’ve seen all this clearly. My dad once explained to me that his dad (my grandpa) was beaten when he misused a tractor. Not spanked, but beaten. We hear that and think how horrible, how unreasonable. But my grandpa understood, if he had broken the tractor he could’ve led the family into a spiral that led to poverty and death. That’s how much capitalism and the industrial revolution continues to change the world, just a few generations ago a severe beating was seen not as abuse but as necessary family protection. The stakes are much lower now because material wealth has increased for everyone, at least in the west.
Jesus shows the father from the beginning to be what the gen zers call a simp. He doesn’t do what he should’ve done according to the justifiable moral standards of the day. That son needed correction and he didn’t give it to him. He sacrifices the family wealth to give the son what he wanted, then looks for the son to repent day after day. How do we know that? He saw the son coming from far away. He was constantly looking for him to return, then debases himself in the eyes of the community by exposing his legs and running to the son. He won’t even let the son finish his speech, he brings him back into the family without him having to earn anything. God’s love for us is so much bigger than economics, politics, race, sex or anything we can think of that gives humans pleasure or meaning or value. Gods love for us is semi irrational (not actually irrational but from our perspective it can’t be fully comprehended). God’s love is incomprehensible in terms of its vastness. It bears all things in itself. Notice too that at the end of the story, a story that’s never resolved, the elder brother stays outside. Who stays outside with him? The father. The story ends with the father outside the home with the lost elder brother. Incomprehensible love.
Michael Heiser used to say that he wasn’t going to argue about what kind of slavery was or wasn’t condoned in scripture because it doesn’t really matter for understanding what God thinks of it. The story starts in a garden with no slavery, and ends in a world with no slavery. This is unremarkable to us because slavery isn’t a part of our lives anymore, but to the people who wrote the Bible, people who saw slavery every single day, brutal forms of slavery that we can barely imagine, they saw that God didn’t have slavery when things were the way he wanted it. In God’s kingdom there’s no slave or free, all our one united in eternal love. Incomparable and incomprehensible love.
