Alvin plantinga basically resolved the problem of evil, from a logical perspective anyway. But it persists.
Here’s one way people formulate it now. Let’s say you’re walking by a pond and a baby is drowning in the pond. Aren’t you morally obligated to dive in and try to save the baby? Unless there’s some kind of extenuating circumstance like you’re wheelchair bound or you were on your way to help your own sick child or something then most of us would think yeah. So the conclusion is God allows drowning babies to die everyday and he doesn’t help them. Either he sucks or he can’t save them or he doesn’t exist.
Well here’s some reasons to doubt this way of thinking. Sure a finite person walking along has a duty to act this way. But God made the baby, and the water and the chemicals that are combined to make the water. I think it’s safe to say such a being does not have the same moral duties as a human.
God as a being isn’t exactly analogous to some finite creature who happens upon suffering. So it isn’t exactly clear at all what his duties (if he has any) would be towards a drowning baby. That sounds cruel, because from our perspective it is, but if the classical theist view of God is true then his perspective is very different from ours. Even calling it a perspective at all is somewhat silly.
A friend pointed out to me that during the Angel of death scene from the Prince of Egypt the souls of the first born of Egypt are taken up into heaven. It’s not clear that’s exactly what’s happening but after a child is killed you hear something like an exhalation and then a little light go out and up into the sky. I’m not sure what the filmmakers intent was here but let’s say that something like this was going on in the Passover. It would make alot of sense. Yahweh tells the people in their preparation for Passover that He will be the angel of death, he will be the one to Passover them, and that part of what this is all about is that God is going to judge all the gods of Egypt. What if part of that judgment was claiming or reclaiming all the first born of Egypt for Himself? What if the death of the firstborn was reclamation of God’s rightful ownership of Egypt against the gods they had come to worship? This makes some sense when we look at the redemption of the first born in the Torah, there’s debate over how much this is in relation to actual human sacrifice but regardless of that Yahweh was definitely saying that the firstborn of Israel belonged to Him rightfully and the way you “got them back” from God was by making an offering. God owns us.
The point is that God is weird. There’s no way around that. He dwells in a cloud of mystery and unknowing. We are infantilized intellectually if we keep trying to make him just our buddy, who thinks and feels the same way we do about everything, pretending He has the same moral duties we have.
Here’s a great scene from the magician’s nephew:
“But please, please - won't you - can't you give me something that will cure Mother?'
Up till then he had been looking at the Lion's great feet and the huge claws on them; now, in his despair, he looked up at its face. What he saw surprised him as much as anything in his whole life. For the tawny face was bent down near his own and (wonder of wonders) great shining tears stood in the Lion's eyes. They were such big, bright tears compared with Digory's own that for a moment he felt as if the Lion must really be sorrier about his Mother than he was himself.“My son, my son," said Aslan. "I know. Grief is great. Only you and I in this land know that yet. Let us be good to one another."
Of course Digory does get to heal his mother. But God didn’t heal Lewis’ own mother. Which is the real magic in this passage. Lewis is doing something here which can only be understood as a Christian with the full context. He is fixing his own childhood with fiction but also giving us the secret of abiding faith. Yes in real history his mother died, but that’s not how her story has really ended. Her and Lewis’ story isn’t over and praise be to God it never will be. Gods duties to us are much more like the duties an author has to characters in a novel then they are the duties of the characters in the novel. What’s really strange is that the author became a character and took all our sins and sufferings onto himself, because they make him sadder than they make us. He really comprehends, truly comprehends our own pain better than we ever could and it grieves him more than it could possibly grieve us. The choice to create was the choice to suffer, and that’s the weirdest thing about God. He chose to stop being perfectly happy so we could exist and know his love. We owe Him everything and He owes us nothing and to pretend otherwise is foolish. That isn’t going to stop us questioning, but where did God ever really stop us questioning? The Psalms are full of complaints, questions, fears and doubts. Because God understands that we don’t understand, and that is the most comforting thought of all. God knows and understands us when we don’t understand ourselves or Him.
