I’ve been meaning to do a longer post on this since discovering the true meaning of Sleepy Hollow, specifically for the Abbeville Institute because I think Irving was working from a distinctly anti Yankee perspective. I think that Irving wrote a distinctly anti New England horror story where the hero is actually the headless horseman (whether he’s actually Bram Bones in disguise makes no difference) preserving the integrity of the community from the carnivorous lechery of Yankee capitalism represented by Ichabod Crane. There’s so many interesting things to this story, but it seems very clear that Ichabod is the villain. His name for one, and his obsession with witchcraft, and greed. Even the one mention of black people in the story seems to be negative regarding Ichabod, they marvel at his dancing because it is bizarre and off putting. But the lynch pin is this quotation:
“Besides there is no encouragement for ghosts in most of our villages, for they have scarce had time to take their first nap, and turn themselves in their graves, before their surviving friends have travelled away from the neighbourhood; so that when they turn out at night to walk the rounds, they have no acquaintance left to call upon. This is perhaps the reason why we so seldom hear of ghosts except in our long-established Dutch communities.”
People move on too quickly for ghost stories to develop is the point he’s making. This is why ghost stories are normal and conservative. Irving thinks that ghost stories are culture, real traditional culture of belonging to a place. So the headless horseman defends the community against Ichabod. And this is true no matter how you interpret the horseman. If the horseman is ultimately a figment of Ichabod’s imagination then the story itself is what scares away Ichabod making the night landscape too much for him to handle and drives him away. If it’s actually Bones in disguise then he’s acting like a Zorro or Batman type figure. And if it’s a real spectre then this ghost protects the community almost like a guardian angel. Either way Ichabod is bad and the horseman, while dangerous, is ultimately a force for good. I’ve been meaning to do this longer analytical piece but I keep forgetting. I wanted it to be in line with Halloween in particular but whatever, I’ve started the conversation, I can finish it later.
