Jesus said a lot of crazy things. Stuff too complicated to understand, stuff too simple, and some stuff just too hard. We have tamed Jesus in America, made him in our own image. It’s like pretending Aslan is a house cat.
The hardest of Jesus’ hard sayings comes after he teaches his disciples to pray the Lord’s Prayer. He says but if you do not forgive others their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.
Eugene Peterson paraphrased it like this:
“In prayer there is a connection between what God does and what you do. You can’t get forgiveness from God, for instance, without also forgiving others. If you refuse to do your part, you cut yourself off from God’s part.
I think that makes some sense. But at the end of the day Jesus says your ability to forgive is an essential part of your own forgiveness. What a terrifying thought. I’m not saying it doesn’t make sense, because it does. That’s what makes it so scary, not its absurdity but it’s certainty. Why would God forgive us if we can’t forgive others?
I have so much un forgiveness in my heart. I say the words, feel like the anger and resentment leaves, and then years later something brings all the pain back. And I think there’s a difference between still being hurt and un forgiveness, but that difference is hard to negotiate sometimes. Especially when trying to determine what sort of boundaries you should have with people who have seriously wronged you. And wisdom says boundaries are an important part of dealing with sin because you shouldn’t enable people to sin against you, you shouldn’t be opening yourself to unnecessary hurts or others to sin. Life involves enough risk and unknown dangers, when the dangerous people make themselves known you need to hold them accountable for their own sake as much as yours.
But I started to think about how exactly a human heart can truly forgive all the awful things that happen to us in life. Because Jesus is saying it’s necessary for your salvation. A lot of people, especially Protestants won’t like that phrasing, but that’s why I think this is Jesus’ hardest saying. And I’m not claiming I understand it, just that we need to submit to this. Forgiveness is not optional. So how do we do it? Because real forgiveness is starting to look impossible to me…and I think that’s because without God’s grace it probably is.
First I think Peterson’s way of phrasing Jesus’ teaching is helpful, especially considering the context which is God as father providing for our needs. This is not some disciplinarian scolding you to forgive, this is a loving father sharing with us through his Son, the way salvation works. He is saying this is how it is, if you don’t forgive you don’t get forgiven. Not because I’m mad at you but because that’s just the way the deep magic works.
Second you can still believe in justification by faith and realize that salvation is not encapsulated by that doctrine. All the reformers believed works were necessary for salvation, but they all maintained Sola Fide. Salvation is bigger than Sola Fide. For the Anglican baptism saves, and every time you eat Christ’s flesh as a baptized follower of Jesus you are saved. Lots of stuff saves us in someway, sola fide is part of that story but not its entirety.
Third if you think, as I do in this case, that a task is probably completely impossible apart from supernatural activity then you are going to have to do it with God’s help. To me the idea of total forgiveness is like Peter walking on the water. It’s only possible with Jesus and by Jesus. If you can’t forgive, if you can’t understand how forgiveness works you must look at Jesus. You can’t look at yourself because in this you are the enemy, you are the obstacle, the water that needs to be walked on is your very heart. So look at Jesus in faith and say Lord help me to forgive as you do, I cannot on my own.
Forgiveness is not optional. We’ve got to figure out how to do it, otherwise we’re lost. Thankfully we have help. We just need to keep looking to Jesus.

When I saw the title of your post I thought Matthew 5:44. But then I guess that is the same as forgiving your enemy.