A very nice gentleman recently told me that penal substitution is a wicked and evil doctrine. I haven’t thought much about penal substitution until recently and this got me thinking about it.
NT Wright is infamous for not holding to PS and instead holding to a Christus Victor model of the atonement. The irony being that NT Wright does believe in PS and as far as I can tell has never not held to it, he just thinks that the victor and the penal are parts of what Jesus did and some Christians have made PS all of the atonement, all and nothing more. In an interview he said that these kinds of Christians have made John 3:16 into “For God so hated the world that he killed his son.”
This seems to be the most popular take from internet atheists, prog Christians, and sadly it is often what we feel or vibe from some reformed types as well. Divine child abuse it’s often called. This seems absurd, not least because it doesn’t accord with scripture, least of all John 3:16.
The first time I encountered the idea that there were models of the atonement I think I was in high school. My dad handed me the latest counterpoints volume. I read it and he asked me which one I thought was right. I said all four, it’s clear that all four are right. He nodded and agreed with me. I can’t remember, and I’m not looking up what those views were, but I’m certain Christus Victor and penal substitution were two of them. (I think it was four…Ransom and Moral exemplar were the other two I think).
The atonement is, to put it mildly, profound. If Dostoevsky or Melville can mean more than one thing and have depths of deep plumbing how much more the work of Christ? It’s not surprising at all that multiple things could be true of the atonement. This seems to be NT Wright’s view. It’s not just one thing but several.
Ever since Gustav Aulen’s book Christus Victor nearly a century ago, many have thought that we have to choose between the theme of the cross as victory and the theme of the cross as substitutionary. Many who want to insist on substitution have therefore felt obliged to reject ‘victory’; many who are anxious about ‘substitution’ have gone for ‘victory’ instead. But in fact they belong closely together. The two strands interpret each other and can’t properly be understood separately…In the New Testament, in fact, all the various theories, the so-called ‘models’ that later theologians have come up with, rush together into a larger, more complex whole. And when we preach or teach about the cross, though you can never lay it all out in a single sermon, we need to be aware of the larger biblical picture whenever we are handling the smaller details and the specific texts.
That’s Wright from a talk he gave in preparation for Lent several years ago.
To me it’s puzzling that PS seems to be the one that theologians try to exclude. It is the model that seems the easiest to explain and understand and yet also winds up being the one that no one likes. It’s just so odd to me that this is the one that draws so much vitriol. Especially because I’m not really sure how PS doesn’t emerge from the other theories, and to me that was what I saw in that counterpoints volume, not just that it’s possible to interpret the atonement in different ways but that the different ways actually reinforce and resonate within each other.
For instance let’s say this is what the atonement is: you owe God a debt you can’t pay so God paid it for you. If you can’t pay that debt you will be trapped forever in your sin and go to hell. If this is true when God pays your debt, whether you accept the payment or not, Christ is victorious over hell. He has defeated evil by making it possible for you to be saved. And it’s not hard to see how this is also a Ransom, or how it’s morally exemplary. Your ransom was paid and you’re now free and you should likewise imitate Christ towards others, laying down your life and forgiving their debts. In this case we started with a debt, which in this case seems to me to be analogous to a punishment. Someone convicted of a crime owes to the law their time, freedom etc. That’s what a penalty is, something owed. If I don’t pay the bridge toll because I’m in a hurry I get a letter in the mail next month saying what I owe the toll company.
In the case of Jesus he paid that debt for all of us for all time. This is very simplified language but I’m using it to demonstrate that PS really isn’t that offensive.
Here’s another quote from NT Wright:
The clearest substitutionary passage in Romans, third, is chapter 8 verses 1 to 4. ‘There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Messiah Jesus’, Paul writes, because – cutting to verse 3 – God has sent his own son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and as a sin-offering; and, right there in the flesh, he condemned sin’. for the avoidance of all doubt, this is definitely penal: there is no condemnation . . . because God condemned sin. And it is definitely substitutionary: sin has been condemned in the death of the representative Messiah, so that there is ‘no condemnation’ for those who are ‘in him’. But notice two things. First, he doesn’t say that God condemned Jesus. He says that God condemned sin in the flesh of Jesus. That may not seem much, but actually it’s huge. And, second, here as in Galatians 3 the result is not ‘so we can be forgiven and go to heaven’– heaven isn’t mentioned in Romans 8 – but so that humans can be remade by the Spirit, ahead of their ultimate remaking in the resurrection, and, as in Revelation, can play their parts in God’s new creation.
Let’s end with Isaiah 53, which really is unmistakably about PS, but not in some angry insane cosmic punishment way, but in the way that John 3:16 really means that God gave Himself so that we could be reconciled to Himself, that we who were orphaned could be adopted into God’s family and become caretakers of the new creation alongside Him.
Surely he took up our pain
and bore our suffering,
yet we considered him punished by God,
stricken by him, and afflicted.
But he was pierced for our transgressions,
he was crushed for our iniquities;
the punishment that brought us peace was on him,
and by his wounds we are healed.
We all, like sheep, have gone astray,
each of us has turned to our own way;
and the Lord has laid on him
the iniquity of us all.He was oppressed and afflicted,
yet he did not open his mouth;
he was led like a lamb to the slaughter,
and as a sheep before its shearers is silent,
so he did not open his mouth.
By oppression and judgment he was taken away.
Yet who of his generation protested?
For he was cut off from the land of the living;
for the transgression of my people he was punished.
He was assigned a grave with the wicked,
and with the rich in his death,
though he had done no violence,
nor was any deceit in his mouth.Yet it was the Lord’s will to crush him and cause him to suffer,
and though the Lord makes his life an offering for sin,
he will see his offspring and prolong his days,
and the will of the Lord will prosper in his hand.
After he has suffered,
he will see the light of life and be satisfied;
by his knowledge my righteous servant will justify many,
and he will bear their iniquities.
Therefore I will give him a portion among the great,
and he will divide the spoils with the strong,
because he poured out his life unto death,
and was numbered with the transgressors.
For he bore the sin of many,
and made intercession for the transgressors.
