American Dispensationalism has been dying a slow death in large part because much of the classic formulations of the theology were unbiblical. I say this as a dispensationalist myself who grew up completely within that world. But it’s been having a real moment of popular failure because Americans are finally becoming sick of Israel being treated as the 51st state.
I’m what’s called a progressive dispensationalist. Dispensationalism has had many iterations, some of which were very weird, and its legacy is complicated to say the least. But the kind of dispensationalist I am is not that weird or complicated, in fact dispensationalism today (at the intellectual level of academics etc) is basically where Spurgeon was a hundred and fifty years ago. Spurgeon hated dispensationalism but he believed in what’s called premillenialism and that the reason for the millennium was to restore ethnic or national Israel. In other words he believed in an Israel based millennium. That is basically what it means to be a progressive dispensationalist. The idea is that Israel has not been replaced by the church, there still exist Jew and Gentile in God’s redemptive program but they are supposed to live at peace with each other in Christ, and when Christ returns he will rule as a Davidic king from Jerusalem restoring Israel and uniting the whole planet in peace. As far as I can tell nothing in the New Testament denies this and to me it’s the most consistent biblical eschatology. I hold this all pretty loosely though. Pre millennialism was the only view espoused in the early church up till the time of Augustine, similar to the watcher interpretation of Genesis 6 (which I think dispensationalism is connected to but I’ve never seen any work done on the relationship between them). At least premil is the only view directly articulated by anyone writing on the subject, it seems like they are responding to another view that existed but it’s not articulated.
In the 20th century George Eldon Ladd sort of created an intellectually respectable version of premil called historic premil, but really there is no such thing as historic premil because there was no consistent articulation of premil. I think Ladd’s premil should be called non Israel based premil. He did not think there was a future Israel everything had been fulfilled by Jesus in the church. This is why Ladd’s premil was not enduring. People like John Piper adhered to it because it allowed them to avoid looking like dispensational loonies while still taking the most common sense and straightforward reading of revelation 20. But if there’s theological grounding for the millennium, no reason for it, the view which will emerge more commonly is amillennialism. And that seems to have happened for the most part in contemporary America.
But replacement theology is becoming very publicly popular again and it has been a consistent piece of Christian theology throughout time, much more so than premil or dispensational thought. But whereas I see nothing in the New Testament explicitly arguing against Israel based premil I do see alot that works against replacement theology, particularly within the most prominent proof texts for replacement theology. Auron Macintyre promoted it recently on his podcast. He did a breakdown of the Mike Huccabee interview by Tucker, and there was a lot of good stuff there. Auron is always worth listening to but he claimed that Galatians teaches replacement theology. He didn’t call it that but that’s what he ultimately did.
Galatians can only be teaching replacement theology if you think Paul believed in transgender ideology. He says there is neither Jew nor Greek in Christ Jesus, and that’s where replacement theologians stop. You see! There’s no Jews anymore only Christians! That’s not what Paul is saying at all and he definitely wasn’t saying that at the time because I don’t think he had either modern concept in mind, the church was primarily Jewish at that point. But even if he was distinguishing between the modern concept of Jew and Christian what he would be saying is that Jews and non Jews are both Christians, not that Jews no longer exist. He’s saying they are united in Christ. And this point is one reason why older dispensational thought had to change, there’s not two ways to heaven, there’s just Jesus. But that’s not a denial that there’s this thing called the Jews. Greeks and gentiles don’t need to become Jews to be saved, that was the heresy Paul was dealing with in Galatians, the Judaizers claimed gentiles couldn’t come to Christ as gentiles they had to become Jews. Paul vehemently denies this, and truthfully it was never true in the Torah or even Paul’s own time. You could live in a saving relationship to Israel’s God without becoming part of Israel. There are numerous examples of this. But Paul doesn’t make that argument in Galatians, he’s more concerned with the issue at hand which is that Judaism isn’t what saves Jesus is. So past forms of dispensational thought were wrong when they had a Jewish path to heaven and a gentile path. It’s always been the God who saved Israel from Egypt that saves. Melchizedek wasn’t Jewish, Abraham offered sacrifice through him to God. The Ninevites didn’t need to become Israelites to repent. Gentile believers in Yahweh during Paul’s time were called Godfearers. You could follow Israel’s God and not be a Jew.
But to get back to the transgender thing unless you think Paul also thinks God is annihilating gender through Christ then Jews do still exist within the church. Because he goes on to say neither male or female, slave or free. Distinctions are not annihilated in Christ rather they are unified in Christ. This is how to avoid replacement theology and stop saying crazy stuff like the Jews don’t exist. McIntyre didn’t exactly say that but that’s sort of the implication, the church has replaced Israel, when what Paul is articulating is that God is actively doing a new thing in Christ whereby Israel is not the primary place God is working and telling his redemption story anymore. But Paul clearly still has a concept of a distinct purpose eschatologically for the Jews in Romans. But there isn’t a hard and fast distinction the way older forms of dispensationalism treated these things, there is continuity between Israel and the church but they aren’t identical concepts. One is primarily about blood and soil, the other is about religious colonization of the planet baptizing everyone into Christ.
The promise to Abraham was that the whole earth would be blessed through his offspring, so I’m not entirely sure how important the specific land promises ever were but I don’t think that Auron’s claim that the land promises are only applicable to the church now makes any sense either. And I also think the idea that current Israel has any theological right to the land is absurd. Israel has no right to anything apart from their relationship to their God which is mediated by the Jewish Messiah Jesus. Israel is a secular state that promotes things that are antithetical to Jesus constantly, that means from the perspective of Paul the state of Israel is not a return to anything but rather perpetual spiritual exile. The kingdom has not been restored to Israel because Jesus does not rule in Israel, secular humanism and liberal democracy rule in Israel.
Paul did not see any contradiction in being Jewish and following the Way in the first century. He kept Torah even offering sacrifice in the temple. But over time “Judaism” became reactionary against what became Christianity due to the specific teachings of the Way, and became something Paul probably would not have recognized as authentic Judaism. In other words the Jewish exile was extended due to rejection of the Messiah. That part of the history is mired in darkness, we don’t really know how the ways were parted but the destruction of the temple in AD 70 certainly was involved somehow. But God wants all peoples to be baptized and redeemed through Jesus, this includes the Jewish people (however you categorize them, which is not easy to do). The Jewish people have not been replaced by the church in Paul’s understanding rather the ecclesia of Christ includes them and was based originally in them. All Israel will be saved because all true Israel is to be found in their relationship to Yahweh, not land but God.
This is not an espousal of Christian Zionism because I think it’s an obvious rejection of the current state of Israel as having much in the way of theological significance, it may turn out to be fulfillments of prophecy in the long run but that’s far from clear at this point given how anti God Israel is as a secular state, and how far from true religion Judaism in general has become. There’s nothing strange about the doctrine of the trinity from an authentic Old Testament perspective, the so called strict monotheism of Judaism develops in reaction to Christianity. Trinitarian ideas are developing prior to the first century in Judaism, which is why Paul never struggled with the idea that Jesus was fully identified with the God of Israel. All the prophecies pretty much assume the messiah will be God, just think of the name Immanuel: God with us.
The Jews need to be evangelized and baptized more than they need for Christians to help promote a Jewish homeland. When Jesus returns I believe he will finally bring them home from exile and create true peace in the Middle East. To me this seems to be the best total reading of scripture. There’s never been two paths, there’s always been God and allegiance to Him, Israel (not the secular state but the ancient nation and people) is part of that plan and has not been replaced but Christ is the mediator of a new and better covenant, a universal covenant.
Dispensationalists aren’t the only people who think this way, Jurgen Moltmann who is neither American nor a dispensationalist pretty much came to the same or similar conclusions on his own. His most profound insight though was that amil and premil are functionally the same, postmil (which we haven’t talked about here) is the main point of departure. He thinks amil is really a form of premil and the real fight is between pre and post. That’s a much longer discussion and much more theological. But in conclusion replacement theology isn’t necessary, and there’s nothing in contemporary dispensational thought which should drive political Zionism. Ironically I think politics is now what’s driving replacement theology, obviously weird theology is still driving some American Zionism but that’s all I’ve got time for today…
